6 Best Wilton Cookie Sheets 2025 in the United States

The Wilton Perfect Results Premium Non-Stick Bakeware Cookie Baking Sheets Set is a solid choice for anyone who enjoys baking. These sheets are made of durable steel, ensuring they can handle repeated use without warping. They come in two sizes: medium (15.25 x 10.25 inches) and large (17.25 x 11.5 inches), offering flexibility for different baking needs, whether you’re making cookies, roasting vegetables, or preparing appetizers.

The thickness of the sheets contributes to even heat distribution, which is crucial for consistent baking results. The non-stick surface is a significant advantage, making it easy to remove baked goods without leaving residue. This feature, combined with their dishwasher-safe nature, also simplifies cleanup. However, while the non-stick coating is durable, it is still prone to scratching, so it’s essential to avoid using metal utensils.

The edges are designed to be easy to grip, which helps when handling hot pans, and their nesting design allows for compact storage. Some users might find the sheets a bit heavy, and the non-stick coating may wear off over time with frequent use. These baking sheets are versatile and reliable, making them a good addition to any kitchen for both amateur and experienced bakers.

The Wilton Gold Premium Non-Stick Small Baking Sheet is a solid choice for home bakers who want a dependable and easy-to-use cookie sheet. Made from steel with a non-stick coating, it ensures baked goods release easily and cleanup is simple, especially since it’s dishwasher safe and scratch-resistant. Its size (about 13 x 9 inches) fits well in most ovens and is perfect for small batches of cookies or roasting.

At roughly 0.6 inches thick, it offers good heat distribution without warping, so your cookies bake evenly. The edges are slightly raised, helping prevent spills or dough from sliding off, which is handy during baking. Being free of PFAs means it’s a safer option for health-conscious users. Since it’s a smaller sheet, it might not suit those who regularly bake large batches at once. Also, while the non-stick coating is durable, non-stick surfaces generally require gentle care to maintain their performance over time.

With an oven-safe temperature up to 450°F, it’s versatile for many baking and cooking needs beyond cookies. The 10-year limited warranty adds peace of mind, making this baking sheet a reliable addition to any kitchen focused on quality and convenience.

The Wilton Non-Stick Cookie Pans, 3 Piece Value Set, offers a versatile baking solution with three different sizes of cookie pans. Made from aluminum, these pans are lightweight and offer good heat distribution for even baking. The nonstick surface ensures that cookies and other baked goods release easily, reducing the need for additional greasing and making cleanup a breeze.

The light gray color of the pans helps prevent over-browning, which can be beneficial for achieving consistent baking results. However, the nonstick coating means these pans are not dishwasher safe and require hand washing, which could be a drawback for some users. The shallow lip around the edges makes these pans versatile for other cooking tasks, such as roasting vegetables, adding to their practicality.

Despite being reasonably durable, the thickness might not be as robust as some users would prefer, especially for heavy-duty baking tasks. The set's value is enhanced by the inclusion of three pan sizes, catering to various baking needs. The Wilton Non-Stick Cookie Pans are a good choice for home bakers looking for convenience and versatility in their bakeware, but those seeking heavy-duty, dishwasher-safe pans might want to consider other options.